Robotic cats, dogs and therapy robots for aged care homes, dementia units and families across Australia. · Call 0485 939 966

What robotic pets cannot do

Limits of robotic pets in aged care: a 2025 review of 15 trials found no effect on cognition or depression, plus distress, ethics and upkeep to plan for.

What robotic pets cannot do

The trials so far show no improvement in memory, thinking or depression from robotic pets, and they do not help everyone. Their best-supported effect is less agitation and anxiety for some people while they use them. They can also upset some residents, they raise fair questions about honesty and dignity, and they need batteries, cleaning and staff attention. Treat a robotic pet as one non-drug option to try and review, never as a treatment.

What does the research not show?

The most recent pooled analysis, by Fan and colleagues in the Journal of Medical Internet Research in 2025, covered 15 randomised trials with 705 participants. Robots lowered agitation and anxiety levels. These measures showed no significant pooled effect: cognitive function, neuropsychiatric symptoms, depression, quality of life, daytime step count and night-time hours lying down. The authors suggest longer programs may work better.

Other studies add more limits:

  • In the Griffith University trial of 415 residents in 28 Queensland facilities, the robot seal beat a switched-off plush version only on engagement. Agitation measured by staff on the Cohen-Mansfield short form showed no difference between the groups.
  • A follow-up analysis of 138 residents who used PARO in that trial found that people with severe agitation at the start responded poorly. The authors recommend limiting PARO to people with low to moderate agitation.
  • A 2023 review of 51 studies of real and robotic animal programs found most had methodological limitations, so its authors call the findings preliminary.
What you may hear What the studies found
It improves memory No significant effect on cognitive function in the 2025 pooled analysis
It treats depression No significant pooled effect on depression
It calms agitation Pooled results and video observation show less agitation; a staff-rated scale did not
It works for severe agitation Residents with severe agitation responded poorly in the Queensland data
It cuts medication Not shown by the large trials; see robotic pets and antipsychotic use

The positive side of the evidence is summarised in what the research says about robotic pets.

What if a robotic pet causes distress?

Dementia Support Australia’s care staff helpsheet on simulated pets says plainly that this activity is not suitable for everyone living with dementia. The risks it names:

  • A pet can bring back bad memories for someone who was once hurt by an animal, or who is grieving a pet they lost.
  • Some people find it childish. The helpsheet says to remove it if the person is distressed or calls it childish.
  • A person who becomes attached may be upset when it is taken away, which is why the helpsheet says to decide early whether the pet is shared or theirs alone.
  • Someone caring for a pet all day may neglect their own needs, for example feeding the pet and skipping their own meal.
  • Other residents calling it a toy can upset the person who believes it is real.
  • People who never liked animals are less likely to respond well.

In shared lounges, two residents can also want the same pet at the same time. Plan for that before the first session.

The honesty question: is it deceiving the resident?

Ethicists have raised this for more than a decade. Amanda and Noel Sharkey, writing in Ethics and Information Technology (2012), listed deception and infantilisation among six ethical concerns about robots in elder care, along with less human contact and loss of privacy and control.

Australian practice guidance takes a person-led approach. Dementia Support Australia advises staff to respect the person’s own view of the pet: if they treat it as a real cat or dog, do not call it a robot or a toy, and use the name they have given it. If they see it as a novelty, share their enjoyment of it. A workable position for most homes:

  • Offer the pet openly, without claiming it is a live animal.
  • Follow the person’s lead and do not argue about what it is.
  • Explain the purpose to family first, so nobody is surprised.
  • Stop if the person seems confused, distressed or embarrassed.

The resident’s choice and dignity are covered in more depth on robotic pets and the resident’s rights.

What can go wrong with batteries, cleaning, falls and breakage?

Joy for All companion cats and pups run on 4 C alkaline batteries. The maker says battery life depends on how much the pet is used, and the pet goes into a sleep mode when nobody is touching it. The battery cover takes a small Phillips screwdriver, so plan for staff to change batteries. A pet that goes quiet mid-cuddle can upset someone attached to it, so keep spares on hand.

Cleaning is limited. The maker says to spray the fur with a non-toxic toy cleaner, wipe it dry, use a disposable germicidal wipe, brush it, and never soak the fur or put it under running water. It also recommends each person have their own pet where possible, with hand washing before and after use when pets are shared. A pet that cannot be cleaned to your infection control standard should not move between residents.

At about 1.8 kg, a companion pet is light enough to slide off a lap or a chair arm. Expect some wear on the fur, and ask the supplier about warranty and replacement before you buy.

Can it replace people, real animals or a care plan?

A robotic pet gives someone something to hold and talk to. It does not supply conversation, touch from family or the experience of a living animal. The Aged Care Act 2024 gives residents a right to opportunities and help to stay connected with the people who matter to them and with pets, so a robotic pet should never become a reason to cut back visits or animal programs.

It also does not run itself. The Queensland trial used short sessions without a facilitator, yet its cost analysis still found the PARO program cost the provider more per resident than usual care. Staff introduce the pet, watch the response, change batteries, clean it and write it up.

How should you set expectations with families and staff?

  • Describe the aim in plain words: comfort and engagement, measured for each person.
  • Say what it will not do: it will not improve memory or replace medication reviews.
  • Agree a review date and what would make you stop.
  • Record what happens each time, using the introduction checklist.

What to do next

If a robotic pet still looks right for a resident, compare PARO, a companion pet and a plush toy, and weigh other options in robotic pets compared with Tovertafel, VR and tablets. When you know what you want to trial, ask a supplier about a small trial set.

Request quotes

Frequently asked questions

Can a robotic pet improve memory in dementia?

No study we have found shows that. The 2025 pooled analysis of randomised trials found no significant change in cognitive function. A pet may help someone feel calmer or more engaged during use, but it does not slow memory loss.

Can a robotic pet make someone more upset?

Yes. Some people find it childish, some are reminded of a pet they lost or an animal that hurt them, and some become so attached that taking it away causes distress. Watch the first sessions closely and remove the pet if it upsets the person.

Is it dishonest to give a person with dementia a robotic pet?

It can be, if staff tell the person it is alive. Offer it openly, let the person decide what it means to them, and do not argue with how they see it. Involve family in the decision, and stop if the person seems confused or embarrassed.

Will a robotic pet save staff time?

Do not count on it. Staff still introduce the pet, watch how each person responds, clean it, change batteries and record the outcome. In the Queensland cost analysis the PARO program added cost per resident compared with usual care.

What happens when the batteries run out?

The pet stops moving and making sounds, which can worry someone who is attached to it. Keep spare batteries, check them on a schedule, and have staff change them out of the person's sight where possible.

Should a robotic pet replace visits from a therapy dog?

No. Residents have a right to support to stay connected with people and pets that matter to them. A robotic pet can fill the gaps between visits for someone who enjoys it, but it is not a substitute for a living animal or for people.

0485 939 966