Robotic pets for residents without dementia
About 46% of people in permanent aged care in 2021 to 2022 had no recorded dementia. What research from 2013 to 2022 says about robotic pets and loneliness.
A robotic pet can help some lonely residents who do not have dementia, but only when it is offered as their choice and alongside real company, not instead of it. In studies with older people at home and with mixed groups of residents, people cuddled the pet, talked to it and showed it to visitors. Others saw an unfamiliar robot as a toy for children. The evidence for this group is thinner than for dementia, so treat a pet as a trial and watch how the person responds.
Loneliness after moving into residential care
Much of the research on robotic pets is about dementia, yet many residents do not have it. In 2021 to 2022, almost 242,000 people lived in permanent residential aged care and 54% of them were recorded as living with dementia, according to the AIHW’s Dementia in Australia report. That leaves about 46% with no dementia on their record. The AIHW adds two cautions: dementia may not have been recorded for some people, and many residents without a dementia record still had some cognitive impairment. Among residents without dementia, 54% had no, minimal or mild cognitive impairment.
That is a large group of residents, many of whom know exactly what they have left behind. The government’s volunteer visitor scheme lists the reasons older people feel alone: being cut off from their culture and heritage, little contact with friends or relatives, mobility problems that stop them joining in, and being different in some way. Moving into care can bring several of those at once, and some residents also leave a pet behind.
The Strengthened Aged Care Quality Standards ask residential homes to support residents to do the things they want to do, including to minimise boredom and loneliness (Action 7.1.1).
What studies with residents without dementia found
We found few trials limited to residents without dementia, so the useful studies are of mixed groups or people living at home.
| Study | Who took part | What it found |
|---|---|---|
| Robinson and colleagues, 2013, randomised trial | 40 residents in rest home and hospital care in Auckland, New Zealand | Residents in PARO sessions twice a week for 12 weeks had significant falls in loneliness compared with a control group, and talked to and touched PARO more than the home’s resident dog (abstract) |
| Hudson and colleagues, 2020, interviews | 20 lonely older adults living in the community who had a robotic pet | People living alone with fewer social connections and less active lives gained the most; most showed their pet to others, which helped some start conversations |
| Bradwell and colleagues, 2021, focus groups | 65 residents, staff and family members from 5 care homes | Familiar animals were preferred, with the Joy for All cat first and the dog second; unfamiliar robots were more often seen as toy-like and suitable for children |
| Fogelson and colleagues, 2022 | Residents with mild to moderate dementia during COVID-19 restrictions | Depression and loneliness scores improved over 6 weeks with a robotic dog or cat |
The last study involved people with dementia, so it says less about residents without it. Our research summary covers the dementia trials.
Who tends to enjoy a robotic pet and who does not
Drawing on these studies, residents tend to fall into rough groups.
More likely to enjoy one:
- people who had a cat or dog for most of their lives and gave it up on moving in
- people who spend much of the day in their room because of mobility or health
- people who like having something to show and talk about when family visit
Less likely to enjoy one:
- people who see it as a toy and feel talked down to
- people who want a real animal and nothing less
- people who dislike noise, or who share a room with someone who does
A familiar animal matters. In the 2021 focus groups, residents, staff and families preferred a domestic cat or dog with soft fur over unfamiliar designs.
Offering it with respect: a choice, not a toy
The way you offer a pet affects how it is received. Under the Aged Care Act 2024, the Statement of Rights gives each person the right to make their own decisions about how they live and to stay connected with the people who are important to them, their community and their pets. Our page on robotic pets and the Statement of Rights goes through it.
- Describe it plainly: “This is a robotic cat. Some people like having one in their room. Would you like to try it for a week?”
- Do not leave it on the person’s bed or lap without asking, and take it back if they say no.
- Use the person’s own words for it, and do not use baby talk.
- Let them name it, choose the coat colour, and decide who else may touch it.
- Check in after a week or two and record the answer in their care plan.
Other supports: volunteer visitors, real animals and groups
A robotic pet works best as one part of a plan for a lonely resident.
Volunteer visitors. The Aged Care Volunteer Visitors Scheme is a free service that arranges regular visits for friendship and companionship. It works with about 120 community organisations and has run for over 30 years, previously as the Community Visitors Scheme. Residents in government-subsidised care can be referred by their provider or refer themselves.
Real animals. The Statement of Rights includes staying connected with your pets, so ask whether the home allows family to bring in a resident’s own animal, or has visiting animal programs. In the 2013 Auckland trial, both the home’s resident dog and PARO changed the social environment compared with times when neither was present, so a real animal and a robotic one can both have a place.
Groups and outbreaks. Lifestyle groups, outings and shared meals stay part of the plan. When an outbreak confines residents to their rooms, see our outbreak isolation checklist.
Choosing the pet: cat, pup, bird or PARO
| Pet | Price in Australia | Suits | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Companion cat | $259 to $300 | Residents who like to stroke and hold; it purrs and vibrates | Batteries need a screwdriver, so staff should change them for arthritic hands |
| Companion pup | $289 to $315 | Lifelong dog owners and people who talk to their pet; it barks back | Residents with poor hearing may miss the sounds, while the cat’s purr can be felt as well as heard |
| Walker Squawkers bird | $149 to $159 | Residents who use a walking frame and want something cheerful on it | It sings when the walker moves, which a shared room may not welcome |
| PARO seal | $6,500 | Planned one-to-one or small group sessions | At this price it is usually shared, not given to one resident |
The cat and pup each weigh about 1.9 kg according to Dementia Shop Australia’s listings. Our companion pets overview explains the choices, and the robotic birds page covers birds and other animals.
What to do next
Talk with the resident first, then their family. If they want to try one, a single cat or pup is enough for a trial. For a home planning pets for several residents who live without dementia, ask for quotes for personal pets for lonely residents and a supplier will quote you directly.
Frequently asked questions
- Will a resident who knows it is a robot still enjoy a robotic pet?
Some will and some will not. In a 2020 American interview study, lonely older people living at home petted, groomed and slept with their robotic pets, and used them to start conversations. Other people find any robot toy-like. The only way to know is to offer it as a trial and accept the answer.
- Do robotic pets reduce loneliness in aged care?
There is some evidence they can. A 2013 randomised trial in an Auckland rest home and hospital found PARO sessions lowered loneliness over 12 weeks compared with normal activities, and a 2022 study found lower loneliness scores among residents with mild to moderate dementia. The trials are small, and none shows a pet replacing contact with people.
- Is a visit from a real animal better than a robotic pet?
For someone who loves animals and can manage one, a real animal may be what they want most, and the Statement of Rights includes the right to stay connected with your pets. A robotic pet fills the hours in between and suits residents who cannot have a live animal in their room. In the Auckland trial, residents talked to and touched PARO more often than the home's resident dog, so the two are not simply ranked.
- Can a resident without dementia keep a robotic pet in their own room?
Yes. A pet bought by the resident or their family is their personal belonging, like a radio or a photo. Tell staff so it can be noted in the care plan, keep spare batteries in the room, and agree who changes them if the resident's hands make the battery screw hard to manage.
- How can a family arrange a volunteer visitor as well?
Ask the home to refer the resident to the Aged Care Volunteer Visitors Scheme, or use the enquiry form on the Department of Health, Disability and Ageing website. People receiving government-funded aged care can also refer themselves. A local network member then contacts you to arrange visits, and the service is free.